ModalAI Forum
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Groups
    • Register
    • Login
    1. Home
    2. ROBERT JUDD
    • Profile
    • Following 0
    • Followers 0
    • Topics 2
    • Posts 32
    • Best 1
    • Controversial 0
    • Groups 0

    ROBERT JUDD

    @ROBERT JUDD

    1
    Reputation
    7
    Profile views
    32
    Posts
    0
    Followers
    0
    Following
    Joined Last Online

    ROBERT JUDD Unfollow Follow

    Best posts made by ROBERT JUDD

    • Starling 2 Max no GPS data

      ModalAI Support,

      I received a new Starling 2 Max a few days ago, and overall it's great, but I'm having a problem with GPS. Basically, the drone appears to NEVER receive any GPS signals even when left outside for long periods of time. My system info and results of px4-listener are pasted below.

      This issue appears similar to these other forum discussions, where they seem to think the problem relates to EMI:

      https://forum.modalai.com/topic/3879/gps-not-working-for-starling-2-max/16

      https://forum.modalai.com/topic/3912/problem-acquiring-gps-satellites-possible-voxl2-board-emi?_=1731073406011

      I did unplug the Lepton 8-pin JST SH connector as suggested by James Strawson in the forum discussions above, but that had no effect. I also powered down the WiFI as suggested by Alex Kushleyev, but this also had no effect, although kind of a bad test for me because I couldn't put the drone outside due to USB cable length:

      • pin GPIO_157 controls VBUS, which is USB power on VOXL2
      • to disable, run voxl-gpio write 157 0
      • to enable, run voxl-gpio write 157 1

      What do you think I should do next? Is there some way to turn the power off to various subsystems via software in an attempt to figure out if and where EMI is the problem? Any other ideas?

      Thanks for your help !

      Starling 2 Max Outdoor GPS-denied Development Drone × 1
      with Battery Pack and Controller and Case
      Dual 4k & Dual Tracking & ToF (C29)
      5G WiFi and Ghost Atto 2.4GHz
      ECCN: EAR99, NLR


      system-image: 1.8.02-M0054-14.1a-perf
      kernel: #1 SMP PREEMPT Mon Nov 11 22:47:44 UTC 2024 4.19.125
      hw platform: M0054
      mach.var: 1.0.1
      voxl-suite: 1.4.1
      current IP: wlan0: 10.0.0.19


      voxl2:~$ px4-listener sensor_gps

      TOPIC: sensor_gps
      sensor_gps
      timestamp: 841732144 (0.020669 seconds ago)
      timestamp_sample: 0
      time_utc_usec: 0
      device_id: 11272245 (Type: 0xAC, SERIAL:6 (0x00))
      lat: 0
      lon: 0
      alt: -17000

      alt_ellipsoid: 0
      s_variance_m_s: 999.00006
      c_variance_rad: 3.14159
      eph: 4294967.50000
      epv: 3796926.25000
      hdop: 99.99000
      vdop: 99.99000
      noise_per_ms: 64
      jamming_indicator: 15
      vel_m_s: 0.00000
      vel_n_m_s: 0.00000
      vel_e_m_s: 0.00000
      vel_d_m_s: 0.00000
      cog_rad: 0.00000
      timestamp_time_relative: 0
      heading: nan
      heading_offset: 0.00000
      heading_accuracy: 0.00000
      rtcm_injection_rate: 0.00000
      automatic_gain_control: 0
      fix_type: 0
      jamming_state: 0
      spoofing_state: 1
      vel_ned_valid: False
      satellites_used: 0
      selected_rtcm_instance: 0

      voxl2:~$ px4-listener sensor_mag

      TOPIC: sensor_mag
      sensor_mag
      timestamp: 861420482 (0.006257 seconds ago)
      timestamp_sample: 861420007 (475 us before timestamp)
      device_id: 527625 (Type: 0x08, I2C:1 (0x0D))
      x: -0.04417
      y: -0.32142
      z: 0.42167
      temperature: nan
      error_count: 0
      voxl2:~$

      posted in Ask your questions right here!
      ROBERT JUDDR
      ROBERT JUDD

    Latest posts made by ROBERT JUDD

    • RE: Starling 2 Max no GPS data

      @Alex-Kushleyev Thanks for the update. I had to pivot away from this project and plan to revisit it when ModalAI has a long term fix. Have your colleagues made any progress identifying the source of the EMI?

      Thanks again for your help.

      posted in Ask your questions right here!
      ROBERT JUDDR
      ROBERT JUDD
    • RE: Starling 2 Max no GPS data

      @Alex-Kushleyev Did you have a test flight yet? How did the GPS perform while flying?

      Thanks

      posted in Ask your questions right here!
      ROBERT JUDDR
      ROBERT JUDD
    • RE: Starling 2 Max no GPS data

      @Alex-Kushleyev Very interesting, thanks for the update.

      Regarding the EMI from the Commando 8 transmitter, I wonder what would happen if you removed the Ghost Atto receiver and antenna from the drone. Maybe somehow they are involved in the EMI.

      Noise from the 6-conductor cable is also interesting, I wonder if passing them through an RF shield would make a difference.

      Please let me know the results of your test flight. If it's successful I may do something similar and repeat your testing.

      What ideas do you and your team have for a long term solution? Do you have access to something like SignalHound equipment to search for the source of EMI?

      Thanks
      Bob

      posted in Ask your questions right here!
      ROBERT JUDDR
      ROBERT JUDD
    • RE: Starling 2 Max no GPS data

      @Alex-Kushleyev Have you made any progress with this yet? Please let me know if/how I can help.

      posted in Ask your questions right here!
      ROBERT JUDDR
      ROBERT JUDD
    • RE: Starling 2 Max no GPS data

      @Alex-Kushleyev Got it, thanks. FYI here's an interesting graph regarding the frequency of the EMI from a prior post:

      https://forum.modalai.com/topic/3912/problem-acquiring-gps-satellites-possible-voxl2-board-emi

      posted in Ask your questions right here!
      ROBERT JUDDR
      ROBERT JUDD
    • RE: Starling 2 Max no GPS data

      @Alex-Kushleyev Thanks for the reply, and yes, I'm happy to work with you to find a solution. As an attempt to improve SNR, I took the STEP files and created a "stretched" 3D-printed version of the GPS mount, see below, but I haven't had a chance to install it yet. Based on some previous testing I think the added distance will improve SNR somewhat, and adding some shielding should also help, but I think the best long term solution would be to find the source of EMI and target that. I don't have the equipment or knowledge to do that, however.

      Please keep me posted, and let me know if there's any way I can contribute. Thanks for your help!

      IMG_4511.jpeg

      posted in Ask your questions right here!
      ROBERT JUDDR
      ROBERT JUDD
    • RE: Starling 2 Max no GPS data

      @Alex-Kushleyev Here are the results of testing with a brand new GPS from a different manufacturer (https://holybro.com/products/micro-m10-gps?variant=42981482954941). The GPS is in the same position as the original, but connected to u-center. As with prior tests, Lepton is disconnected and ALFA is removed.

      Top u-center screen shot is with drone powered OFF, bottom is drone powered ON. To me this Holybro GPS looks about the same as the 3DR GPS, i.e. satellite signals drop significantly with drone powered ON. Not shown are results where I found that the satellite signal increased significantly when I moved the GPS module farther away and/or added shielding.

      What do you suggest as next steps?

      Thanks for your help.

      Holybro.jpg

      holybro-gps-drone-off.png

      holybro-gps-drone-on.png

      posted in Ask your questions right here!
      ROBERT JUDDR
      ROBERT JUDD
    • RE: Starling 2 Max no GPS data

      @Alex-Kushleyev will do, thanks!

      posted in Ask your questions right here!
      ROBERT JUDDR
      ROBERT JUDD
    • RE: Starling 2 Max no GPS data

      @Alex-Kushleyev said in Starling 2 Max no GPS data:

      Let me check with the team what the expected signal level is when a properly working Starling 2 Max is receiving GPS.

      Have you had a chance to check on this?

      FYI in the meantime I've purchased 3 additional GPS modules from different manufacturers, and will evaluate them using u-center and the drone when they arrive.

      I need to get this problem fixed somehow - can't fly far without a GPS!

      posted in Ask your questions right here!
      ROBERT JUDDR
      ROBERT JUDD
    • RE: Starling 2 Max no GPS data

      @Alex-Kushleyev 3DR says the replacement GPS won't be shipped until next week. Are there any useful tests I can run while waiting, eg. power down selective subsystems and observe GPS signal via u-center? I did hold the current (potentially defective) GPS module in my hand and move it around the drone while observing signal strength in u-center, but it wasn't clear to me where the interference was originating from. Open to suggestions. Thanks for your help.

      posted in Ask your questions right here!
      ROBERT JUDDR
      ROBERT JUDD